Detailed Institutional Benchmark Table
This table compares 10 institutions (Top 10 Indiana Private Colleges) side by side.
On average, these colleges receive 6,925 applications and admit 3,435, for an average acceptance rate of 72.73% and an average yield rate of 19.91%, with an average SAT of 1209.
University of Notre Dame is the most selective (11.27%) while Bethel University is the least selective (97.66%).
| Institution | Control | Applicants | Admitted | Acceptance Rate | Yield Rate | Median SAT |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| University of Notre Dame | Private | 29,942 | 3,374 | 11.27% | 61.71% | 1520 |
| DePauw University | Private | 6,683 | 3,822 | 57.19% | 13.21% | 1315 |
| Valparaiso University | Private | 6,199 | 5,544 | 89.43% | 9.63% | 1160 |
| Butler University | Private | 9,471 | 8,058 | 85.08% | 12.88% | 1250 |
| Indiana Wesleyan University-Marion | Private | 3,761 | 3,345 | 88.94% | 16.95% | 1080 |
| Hanover College | Private | 2,889 | 2,418 | 83.70% | 14.39% | 1180 |
| Earlham College | Private | 2,075 | 1,517 | 73.11% | 13.91% | 1190 |
| Wabash College | Private | 2,199 | 1,392 | 63.30% | 18.39% | 1170 |
| University of Evansville | Private | 5,044 | 3,914 | 77.60% | 10.60% | - |
| Bethel University | Private | 985 | 962 | 97.66% | 27.44% | 1020 |
10-Year Acceptance Rate Velocity (2016-2025)
Track how selectivity has changed across the top 10 Indiana Private Colleges.
Key Takeaways from Data
Acceptance Rate Trend: The average acceptance rate rose from 65.26% in 2016 to 72.73% in 2025 (+7.46 percentage points).
Becoming More Selective: ND (19.80% in 2015 to 11.27% in 2024) saw the largest drop in acceptance rate, becoming the most improved in selectivity.
Becoming Less Selective: Bethel (66.46% in 2015 to 97.66% in 2024) saw the largest rise in acceptance rate.
10-Year SAT Score Trends (2016-2025)
Track how average SAT scores have changed across the top 10 Indiana Private Colleges.
Key Takeaways from Data
SAT Score Trend: The average SAT score rose from 1144 in 2016 to 1209 in 2025 (+66 points).
Biggest Increase: DePauw (1175 in 2016 to 1315 in 2025) saw the largest increase in average SAT score.
Biggest Decrease: Earlham (1295 in 2018 to 1190 in 2025) saw the largest decrease in average SAT score.
SAT No Longer Reported: UE (last reported in 2023) no longer reports SAT scores, likely having discontinued the SAT requirement or gone test-optional or test-free.
Top 10 Indiana Private Colleges Score Percentile Estimator
Input your SAT or ACT score to instantly compare your profile against the median test score profiles of the top 10 Indiana Private Colleges (10 institutions).
Comprehensive Admissions Analysis
1. Selectivity Surge
Across Top 10 Indiana Private Colleges, ND is the most selective at 11.27%, while Bethel is the least selective at 97.66%. The average acceptance rate is 72.73%, up from 65.26% in 2016 to 72.73% in 2025.
2. Yield & Brand Power
ND has the highest yield rate at 61.71%, while VU has the lowest at 9.63%. The average yield is 19.91%.
3. Standardized Testing
ND has the highest median SAT at 1520, while Bethel has the lowest at 1020. The average SAT of Top 10 Indiana Private Colleges is 1209. 1 of 10 institutions do not report SAT scores.